For almost two years, Jonathan M. Cohen spent 40 percent of
each workweek trying to lure venture capital to his Rockville biotech
company, he said. If 20/20 GeneSystems Inc. could land $3 million
or $4 million dollars, the firm could add more scientists and
researchers, Cohen reasoned, and perhaps turn out the diagnostic test
for lupus it had been developing in two years rather than four.
But in 2004, Cohen quit searching for venture funding. The local
investors he encountered often weren't interested in early-stage
companies like his, and many simply wouldn't consider biotech
investments.
Montgomery County Del. Brian J. Feldman (D) has stories like
that in mind when he talks about the tax credit bill he plans to
introduce in the Maryland legislature. If biotech start-ups can't
attract money to get off the ground, he said, some may languish and
others may die.
Feldman's bill and a similar one backed by Gov. Robert L. Ehrlich
Jr. (R) last week are intended to help young companies by giving
substantial tax breaks to outside investors.
"We've done a good job in terms of research dollars, but when it
comes from taking those research products and commercializing them, we
really lag behind," Feldman said. Maryland has the third-largest
concentration of biotech firms in the nation, a 2003 report by Ernst &
Young found, but it was ninth in the amount of venture funding raised by
companies in the sector between 1995 and 2001.
Feldman's bill would try to spur more funding by allowing individual
investors or individual partners in Maryland venture capital firms to
recoup up to 50 percent of their investment in one of the state's
biotechnology start-ups through a state income tax credit. The bill
would cap the total credits offered at $12 million a year.
Such an incentive might make the risk worthwhile for angel investors
-- wealthy people who put their own money into young companies -- and
persuade venture firms to set up shop in the state, Feldman said. The
increased investment activity could be just what Maryland needs to
supercharge its tech industry, creating more high-paying jobs, he said.
But will venture investors -- the kings and queens of the high-risk,
high-reward model for money management -- change their strategy to gain
a state tax credit?
"I doubt it," said Mark G. Heesen, president of the
National Venture Capital Association. "Their primary responsibility
is to their investors, and their investors are saying, 'We want to you
invest in the best deal possible.' If they are concerned about the tax
consequence, maybe they shouldn't be involved in venture capital."
Ryan M. Brennan, vice president of Advantage Capital
Partners, a venture firm based in St. Louis, agrees that tax
incentives should never be a main driver for any investor, but he said a
program like the one Feldman is proposing could make some funds take a
second look at Maryland. That includes his firm, which he said is
considering opening an office in the state.
Donald J. Rainey, a partner in the Reston office of North
Carolina-based venture firm Intersouth Partners, said he's
skeptical that such a plan would have an impact on venture funds, but he
has seen how much it can influence angel investors. North Carolina
created a similar incentive in the mid-1990s when Rainey was an
entrepreneur there. He said he found it much easier to persuade people
to part with their money when they were guaranteed to get some back.
Ehrlich's plan targets only angel investors but is broader than
Feldman's in that funding could go to any technology start-up, not just
biotech firms. Anyone with a net worth over $1 million could apply for a
45 percent tax credit on investments over $50,000. The legislation would
not allow any investor to recoup more than $200,000 in one year and
would cap the program at $8 million per year.
"We're trying to institute a cultural change in the technology
community here in Maryland," said Christopher C. Foster, the
state's chief technology officer. "We're trying to make it more
entrepreneurial, and we're trying to tell people it's okay to take
risks."
Bolstering technology entrepreneurship is not a new endeavor in
Maryland. The state sponsors 19 incubators that nurture tech start-ups,
and its Department of Business and Economic Development is often the
most active venture investor in the region.
A study last July found that 19 states have established tax credit
programs to spur investments in start-ups.
Ohio has had a tax incentive program for angel investors in place
since 1996. Tax credits totaling $11 million have been issued to 1,470
investors who pumped more than $45 million into 131 companies. But there
are no statistics on how many jobs that money helped create or how the
start-ups fared.
Still, John May, co-founder of the Dinner Club, a Washington
organization of angel investors, describes such programs as an
"interesting experiment." They may not make conservative investors dump
their municipal bonds for the newest incubator company on the block, he
said, but they could push some wealthy people to take a gamble on a
promising start-up.
"I'm a big believer that all of these tools are useful," May said,
"and I'm a mild advocate of them."
A bill moving through committees in Virginia's legislature would
essentially remove risk by guaranteeing a 10 percent rate of return to
pension funds, endowments and other institutions investing in venture
capital funds that promise to pump money into tech firms in Virginia.
The sponsor, Del. Harry R. Purkey (R-Virginia Beach) said he's
hoping the appropriations committee will allot $250,000 for a pilot year
of the program.
Back in Maryland, Feldman and aides to Ehrlich said they are
optimistic that with similar bills coming from both sides of the aisle,
some version will be passed this year.
Cohen of 20/20 GeneSystems is cheering them on. His company put a
product on the market that screens suspicious powders for bioterrorism
substances. But the diagnostics test for lupus is still several years
out. With a bit of extra funding, he said, "I think we could cut the
time in half."
Ellen McCarthy writes about the local tech scene every other
Thursday. Her e-mail address is
mccarthye@washpost.com.